The Impact of Design on Clinical Care in Childbirth

Year
2017
Status
Completed
Location
United States
Partners
Ariadne Labs, Robert Wood Johnson Foundation
Focus areas
Healthcare
Project Team
Deb Rosenberg, Amie Shao
Project Team
Deb Rosenberg, Amie Shao

"The Impact of Design on Clinical Care in Childbirth" is a design study examining how the physical environment of birth facilities influences clinical processes and outcomes across the United States.

Although mothers in labor are among the healthiest patients in a hospital, they are often treated in environments designed for the sickest. Research shows that a woman’s likelihood of delivering by cesarean section varies more by hospital than by her personal risks or preferences. Cesarean rates range tenfold—from 7% to 70% depending on the facility—a striking disparity given that up to 45% of c-sections may be avoidable. This raises a critical question: How does the physical design of maternity units affect decision-making in childbirth care?

With support from the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation, MASS partnered with Ariadne Labs—a joint center of Brigham and Women’s Hospital and the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health—to investigate. Our team studied twelve diverse facilities, from independent birth centers to large tertiary hospitals, spanning rural Arizona to metropolitan Boston. By analyzing floor plans and observing care processes, we developed testable hypotheses about how design correlates with clinical outcomes.

Learn more

The study found compelling relationships. Facilities with higher c-section rates tended to have greater room demand (creating pressure on the unit), longer walking distances for staff (increasing workload), fewer collaborative spaces (limiting communication), and less patient-accessible space (discouraging walking, which supports progression of natural labor).

These findings demonstrate that design is not neutral but an active factor shaping childbirth experiences. By reframing labor and delivery units as spaces that support a natural human process rather than sites of crisis, the built environment can foster teamwork, reduce unnecessary interventions, and improve outcomes for mothers and newborns alike.

We published our results in two peer-reviewed academic journals, the Journal of Midwifery & Women's Health and the Health Environments Research & Design Journal